“The true diversity of humanity is this: the luminous and the dark.
To diminish the number of dark, to increase the number of luminous,
that is the aim.
That is why we cry: education, knowledge!
To learn to read is to kindle a fire; every syllable spelled sparkles.
But whoever says light does not necessarily say joy.
There is suffering in the light; an excess burns.
Flame is hostile to the wing.
To burn and yet to fly, this is the miracle of genius.
When you know and when you love you will suffer.
The day dawns in tears. The luminous weep, be it only for the dark ones.”
― Victor Hugo
(prematurely fallen muscadine / Julie Cook / 2019)
See the picture above?
At first glance, you see some sort of greenish greyish orb perched in the middle,
amongst the debris of what must be some sort of woodsy ground.
However, upon further inspection, you will note that the right half of the green orb,
or rather a prematurely fallen muscadine, is the side with actual color,
as is the surrounding area.
The color of life and growth.
The left side appears to be rotting or rotten while the surrounding debris around the
muscadine is equally ashen and grey…as in decaying, rotting and dark.
It is a prime example of contrasting imagery between light and dark, life and death…
With the poor muscadine being caught in the middle.
And if the truth be told, that muscadine, my friends, is more representational of both you
and I then either of us can even begin to imagine.
Light vs dark…
life vs death…
While we are constantly suspended between the two.
It’s as if each one vies for our very being.
The endless struggle for mankind.
That struggle is much more active and much more real than most of us care to admit,
let alone contemplate…as the forces of both light and dark, life and death, continuously
wage battle over our very existence.
Metaphors, yes…yet also very much a reality.
I started an interesting book the other day, The Shadow Party
How George Soros, Hillary Clinton, and the Sixties Radicals seized control of
the Democratic Party
by David Horowitz and Richard Poe.
“Ahhh”, you say rather knowingly…” one of ‘those’ types of books.”
A book that speaks of conspiracy and paranoia.
And so now you’re assuming that I am one of those paranoid loons or deplorables
we hear so much about—oh so lovingly nicknamed by Hillary Clinton…
all because I am a conservative individual reading a book that reads like
a Hollywood spy thriller.
Yet the book is much more than a tale of political upheaval, speculation and
The book actually, and perhaps unbeknownst to the authors themselves, speaks to this very
battle of both light and dark, life and death, that I previously referenced…
it’s just that they speak on a level that hits much closer to home than anyone might imagine
as it addresses our life here in America.
There is a great darkness growing in our Nation.
And it is both you and I who hang in the balance.
It is a life that is growing ever more precarious while we are perched between
both light or dark, life or death…
For we are living in some terribly strange times.
This book reminds me of a wonderful post I read the other day by one of my favorite bloggers—
Robert, Bobby, Kloska from Thoughts from the Side of the House.
Bobby is a former professor at Notre Dame who doesn’t
post as often as I or others would wish due to some tremendous health struggles
that get terribly in his way.
His struggles with cancer and the devastating outreaching effects have been an
amazing witness unto themselves.
I, for one, am most grateful that he continues to share both ups and downs.
This past week, for the fourth of July, Bobby wrote about what it is that is
at the root of what many of us believe to be a “crisis” in this Nation of ours.
“Life in America has never been perfect.
In every age, there have been injustices, conspiracies, and controversies.
This is not unique to America; it is part of the human condition.
Yet in America, because we had inherited these noble institutional mechanisms, hope remained.
So long as the republic contained within itself a critical mass of virtuous citizens
committed more to the common good than to privileging any particular sect, group,
or class, then the structures through which we grapple with self-governance could
still yield improvement.”
Today, I have my doubts.
We live in a country that in the span of only a few generations has suddenly lost
any kind of right understanding of objective truth –
as the founding fathers put it in the Declaration of Independence, “…
of the laws of nature and of nature’s God.”
Today, the prevailing understanding of truth is that it is something purely subjective.
This is no small matter.
Today, there has emerged this new idea that you and I supposedly have some kind of
power to create whatever truth we want.
This, of course, not only opens the door to logical self-contradictions,
it very clearly contradicts objective reality itself.
You’re not George Washington even if you think you’re George Washington and
“claim this as your truth.” Simple people see this.
Grounded people see this.
People connected to the earth and nature really see this.
Sophisticates, distracted people, and afflicted people often do not.
What we have is a crisis of truth.
In all human communities, freedom is built upon personal and collective
These responsibilities always rely upon truth.
Our greatest problem today is not simply that we have lost any meaningful concept of truth.
No, it’s worse than that.
Our greatest problem is that 1) we don’t know that truth is something objective to be discovered;
and 2) we no longer have adequate tools to do the work of discovery.
Let that sink in.
We don’t understand that truth needs to be discovered…
and yet everything of consequence depends on this one thing!
The discovery of truth does not come cheaply.
It requires diligence, patience, nuance, thoughtful consideration, and intellectual
To actually discover truth and not merely “win” an argument,
it is enormously helpful to be able to presume the good will and sincerity of one’s
discussion partner. But today our public discourse is largely carried out on Twitter.
News and opinion media have become reactionary and overly polemical.
Even our so-called presidential debates take on the form of a cheap tv game show.
How helpful is that?
Complex questions cannot be answered in one minute sound bytes.
It is folly to even try.
A crisis of truth leads to a crisis of love.
The loss of truth has led to the particularly harmful notion that your disagreement
with one of my ideas is somehow disrespectful of me as a human being.
Tragically, in 2019 America, “disagreement” equals “hate” to a lot of people.
But what if you truly love me?
To love is to will the good of another person.
If I hold an opinion that is not rooted in truth,
then that opinion can be quite harmful to me and to the people I influence.
Isn’t the most loving act to help me discover the truth?
Yes, this might require a discussion, debate, or argument.
Prudence dictates that such discussions occur at the right time,
in the right place, and with appropriate people.
But the premise of these kinds of honest disagreements and discussions is love.
To neglect such conversations with people you supposedly love
(or even with the culture at large)
is to not really love and care about them at all.
At the end of this sobering and somewhat frightening discourse,
Bobby is quick to remind us that not all is lost.
This is not a hopeless situation…
Not hopeless because it is in our hopelessness that our real Hope is to be found.
For in that Hope, resides the One true Everlasting Truth.
The Main Crisis on American Independence Day in 2019
Rejoice in hope, be patient in tribulation, be constant in prayer.
Lots of food for thought here. Thanks Julie!
Interesting. I think more and more people are making the observation that many people don’t understand that objective reality actually exists, and many are making a moral connection too.
If you don’t mind, I expect I will reblog your post and add my own thoughts this evening.
What’s mine is always yours Tom— your additions are the added flavors
[…] wouldn’t we want to know and revere the Truth? Consider this post, we live in both dark and light by Julie (aka Cookie). Consider this […]
thank you Tom for including me in your wonderful and insightful posts
Reblogged this on Talmidimblogging and commented:
Really enjoyed this post Julie, so many good nuggets of info where each one in itself is worthy of a post. Especially this, “The loss of truth has led to the particularly harmful notion that your disagreement with one of my ideas is somehow disrespectful of me as a human being.
Tragically, in 2019 America, “disagreement” equals “hate” to a lot of people.”
Yup, extremely strange times we live in. A bit terrifying too.
Well, I can’t full credit as much oh of the post is the quoting of Bobby’s post—thoughts from the side of the house— the troubling thing in all of this Tricia is that no one really is grasping the fact that we can actually disagree— that is no longer acceptable and that is leading to a totalitarian state of mind— and yet—the youth and left aren’t wise enough to see it— while the likes of George Soros work fast and furious to create such sentiment and turmoil
Yes, but you tied things nicely together and added your the Cookie Special Sauce. I often wonder if the Left really does understand what’s going on and how much they helped contribute to it, but just doesn’t care. A few broken eggs and all, you know? I think some of the diehards are like that and the rest are useful idiots.
That book I’m reading was written in 2006 so reading it and now seeing some of what has come to fruition if absolutely frightening
Wow, I’m going to have to pick that one up!
[…] https://cookiecrumbstoliveby.wordpress.com/2019/07/07/we-live-in-both-dark-and-light/ […]